Sulfide barrier coating or solid electrolyte

ABSTRACT

Provided is a lithium-conductive solid-state electrolyte material that comprises a sulfide compound of a composition that does not deviate substantially from a formula of Li 9 S 3 N. The compound&#39;s conductivity is greater than about 1×10 −7  S/cm at about 25° C. and is in contact with a negative electroactive material. Also provided is an electrochemical cell that includes an anode layer, a cathode layer, and the electrolyte layer between the anode and cathode layers. In an example, the material&#39;s activation energy can be no greater than about 0.52 eV at about 25° C.

RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application claims the benefit, under 35 U.S.C. §119(e), of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 62/205,599 to Miara et al., entitled “Sulfide Barrier Coating and Solid Electrolyte for Metal Anodes and all Solid State Batteries,” filed on Aug. 14, 2015.

BACKGROUND

There is tremendous excitement surrounding solid-state batteries, particularly lithium-based all-solid-state batteries, since they provide a path towards safe, energy dense, and long-life batteries. In particular, sulfide materials have received significant attention as solid electrolytes. However, there remain challenges for adoption such as high interfacial resistance with electrodes and a narrower electrochemical stability window compared to oxide materials. One way to deal with these challenges is to use a combination of materials to act as barrier layers and separators.

SUMMARY

An example of a battery embodiment includes a sulfide compound of a composition that does not deviate substantially from a formula of Li₉S₃N and an anode material electrically coupled to the sulfide compound. The sulfide compound may have a conductivity greater than about 1×10⁻⁷ S/cm at about 25° C. and may be in contact with a negative electroactive material. In some instances, the conductivity is greater than about 5×10⁻⁷ S/cm at about 25° C. In alternative instances, the conductivity is greater than about 1×10⁻⁶ S/cm.

The sulfide compound may be in contact with a negative electroactive material such as metallic lithium at a temperature lower than metallic lithium's melting temperature. Alternatively, the sulfide compound may be in contact with a lithiated anode material having a voltage within about 400 mV from metallic lithium's voltage. Upon contact with the metallic lithium or lithiated anode material, the sulfide compound may exhibit a conductivity of at least 1.0×10⁻⁴ S/cm at a temperature of about 300K. The sulfide compound may be present in an anode barrier coating and/or in an electrolyte. The sulfide compound may be doped or undoped. For example, the sulfide compound may have a formula Li_(9-2x-3y-z)A_(x)B_(y)S_(3-z)C_(z)N₃, where 0≦x<4.5, 0≦y<3, and 0≦z<3. Optionally, the formula may be Li_(9-2x-3y-z)A_(x)B_(y)S_(3-z)C_(z)N₃, where 0.2≦x<0.75, 0.1≦y<0.5, and 0.25≦z<1, wherein A is selected from Ca, Zn, Mg, Cd, Sr, Ba and Be; B is selected from F, Cl, Br, and I, and C is selected from In, La, Be, Y, Sc, Ga and Al. The sulfide compound may have an activation energy no greater than about 1 eV to about 0.6 eV at about 25° C.

In another exemplary embodiment, an electrochemical cell may include an anode layer containing an anode material, a cathode layer containing a cathode material, and an electrolyte layer between the anode and cathode layers. A solid-state, alkali-ion conductive material is present in the cathode layer, the electrolyte layer, or both, the alkali-ion conductive material comprising a sulfide compound of a composition that does not deviate substantially from a formula of Li₉S₃N, having a conductivity greater than about 1×10⁻⁷ S/cm at about 25° C. The cell may be a solid-state rechargeable cell.

In a further exemplary embodiment, a lithium-conductive solid-state electrolyte material may include a sulfide compound of a formula Li_(a)S_(b)N_(c), having a conductivity greater than about 1×10⁻⁷ S/cm and an activation energy no greater than about 0.52 eV at about 25° C., wherein, e.g., 8≦a≦15, 2≦b≦4, 0.5≦c≦3. The activation energy may be no greater than about 0.29 to 0.5 eV at about 25° C.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 illustrates an example of a method embodiment for synthesizing and characterizing an LSN compound in accord with a material embodiment.

FIG. 2 is a graph that shows X-ray diffraction results, at 150% Li₃N, of an example of a material in accord with an embodiment.

FIG. 3 is a graph that fits conductivity results of the exemplary material associated with FIG. 1 from electrochemical impedance spectroscopy.

FIGS. 4-6 illustrate crystallographic unit cells of examples of alternative LSN material embodiments.

FIG. 7 schematically depicts an exemplary electrochemical cell embodiment.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Example embodiments described herein provide a battery that includes lithium-sulfur-nitrogen (LSN) material. For example, the battery can correspond to a solid-state or all-solid-state battery, and the LSN material can correspond to Li₉S₃N material that serves an anode barrier coating, such as a Li-metal barrier coating. The coating can serve to protect an electrolyte from degradation due to contact with Li-metal. Li₉S₃N is an interesting material for use as a Li-metal barrier coating in all solid-state batteries since this form of LSN is stable against reduction, has a higher conductivity than Li₂S, and has better stability than Li₃N.

In example embodiments, substituents can be added to Li₉S₃N. Substituents to a host LSN material tend to increase the conductivity of the host material. Exemplary substituents include Ca and Cl.

In an example embodiment, a barrier coating of Li₃N may be formed by formed by reacting of Cu₃N with Li metal in a reaction: Li+Cu₃N→Li₃N+Cu. The coating formed may protect an electrolyte from degradation due to contact with Li-metal. It will be appreciated that alternative embodiments can omit the barrier coating.

As will be described in greater detail, an example embodiment can facilitate solid-state batteries. Additionally, if substituents such as Cl or Ca are used, the ionic conductivity can be improved compared to other barrier coatings, such as LiPON. Improved ionic conductivity may improve electrolyte performance.

In example embodiments, Ca-substituted Li₉S₃N may be thermodynamically unfavorable. Accordingly, non-equilibrium methods of synthesis can be used. The electrochemical window of this material is small, set by the decomposition of 2Li₃N→6Li+N2 which occurs around 0.44 V vs. Li metal. Thus, Ca-substituted Li₉S₃N may be better suited to Li-metal barrier coatings than as a solid electrolyte in example embodiments. Ca-substituted LSN material may operate up to about 2.0 V compared to Li since Li₂S may form a protective layer. An embodiment such as Li₉S₃N may therefore be advantageous for use as an electrolyte in Li—S batteries or other low voltage cells.

Unless expressly indicated otherwise or indicated otherwise by context, the term “anode” is used interchangeably with the term “negative electrode,” and the term “cathode” is used interchangeably with the term “positive electrode.” The term “electrolyte” as in “solid-state electrolyte” unless expressly indicated otherwise or indicated otherwise by context, can refer to a material through which ions may, under an electric potential gradient, migrate by means of vacancies or interstitials within the material. A number of electrolytes exhibit high ionic conductivity and low electronic conductivity. The terms “substantial” and “substantially” can mean “of considerable importance” or “to a great or significant extent,” but that trivial or insignificant counterexamples may be found, unless expressly indicated otherwise or indicated otherwise by context. For example, a “substantially solid” electrochemical cell may contain trace amounts of fluids like liquids or gases, but such fluids do not hinder or to a great degree negatively affect the performance of the electrochemical cell. Similarly, a “substantially solid-state” battery can correspond to a battery comprising entirely or consisting essentially of solid components, but that the battery does not have to exclude components that are entirely devoid of fluids as long as the operation of the battery is not hindered.

The term “solution” is used in its chemical sense and refers to one or more solutes in a solvent, unless expressly indicated otherwise or indicated otherwise by context. A solution may be fluid or solid in nature. For example, a solid-state solution differs from a solid-state compound in that the crystal structure of the solvent remains unchanged by addition of the solutes and that the solution may remain in a single homogeneous phase. As used herein, an electrically conductive material is a material that supports the transfer of electric charge, for example by mass transport of ionized particles, by electron transport, by hole transport, or by any one or more of these components of electric charge transfer, in any combination. Two materials are electrically coupled to one another when an electrically conductive pathway exists from one of the materials to the other.

Turning now to the figures, FIG. 1 illustrates an example of a method embodiment 100 for synthesizing and evaluating an LSN compound. A compound embodiment produced by the method of FIG. 1 may be suitable for use in a battery embodiment. Beginning at block 102, starting compounds Li₂S (99.9% Alfa Aesar or equivalent) and Li₃N (99.5% Strem Chemicals or equivalent) are mixed with 50% excess Li₃N by weight. In block 104, the mixture may be mechanically milled for 1000 min at a rotating speed of 400 rpm using a planetary ball mill with a ZrO₂ pot and ZrO₂ balls. In block 106, the milled mixture may be placed in a boron nitride crucible and sealed in an evacuated quartz tube. In block 108, the mixture sealed in the quartz tube may be heated to about 600 Celsius for 24 hours in a muffle furnace and slowly cooled to room temperature. In block 110, the purity of the resultant LSN compound may be evaluated, for example by x-ray diffraction with Cu—K α radiation.

Continuing with the example of FIG. 1, at block 112 a blocking electrode setup may be made by pressing the LSN powder from block 108 under about 300 MPa into a pellet of 1.3 cm diameter and ˜1 mm thickness. At block 114 the LSN pellet from block 112 may be sandwiched between two approximately 0.05 mm thick indium foil electrodes and pressed under about 100 MPa. This assemblage may be put in a test cell in some embodiments having a stainless steel outer casing and a Teflon insulator. At block 116, the electrochemical impedance of the LSN compound may be measured, for example with an impedance spectrometer between approximately 1 MHz and 10 mHz.

FIG. 2 is a graph 200 that shows X-ray diffraction results, at 150% Li₃N, of an example of a material in accord with an embodiment. In particular, material corresponds to a sample of contain a mixture of Li₉S₃N and Li₂S. The horizontal axis 202 of the graph represents a range of diffraction angles. The vertical axis 204 of the graph represents intensity of diffracted Cu-Kα radiation. The graph shows two plots 206, 208. The top plot 206 represents raw data. The bottom plot 208 represents the reference diffraction pattern of pure Li₉S₃N, as obtained from the Inorganic Structure Database (id#240749).

FIG. 3 is a graph 300 that fits conductivity results of the exemplary material associated with FIG. 1 from electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. The horizontal axis 302 of the graph represents a range of temperatures. The vertical axis 304 of the graph represents a range of measured conductivities. The graph includes a plot 306. As depicted in FIG. 3, results show that the material is a nearly pure phase and has a conductivity of up to about 3.2×10⁻⁶ S/cm at room temperature, the conductivity of the material measured at various temperatures. The material also exhibited an activation energy of about 0.52 eV. The purity and associated conductivity of the material renders the material suitable for use either as a barrier material or an electrolyte material depending on the required power and/or energy density of a particular electrochemical system (note, other levels of purity may be desirable or acceptable). For example, such an exemplary material may be used in solid lithium ion batteries associated with cell phones, tablet computers, power tools, electric automobiles, etc.

In order to improve conductivity, substitution energy of possible substituents was calculated with first principles based on density functional theory. Table 1 lists various doped LSN materials with their accompanying theoretical substitution energy.

TABLE 1 Substituent Chemical E_(substitute) Volume Density (Kröger-Vink) formula (eV/substituent) (Å³) (gm/cc) — Li₇₂S₂₄N₈ — 1333.61 1.71 Cl_(S)* Li₇₁S₂₃N₈Cl 0.115 1341.79 1.71 Br_(S)* Li₇₁S₂₃BrN₈ 0.330 1348.51 1.75 S_(N)* Li₇₁S₂₅N₇ 0.452 1365.32 1.69 I_(S)* Li₇₁S₂₃IN₈ 0.528 1356.85 1.80 Ca_(Li)* Li₇₀CaS₂₄N₈ 0.848 1358.04 1.72 Zn_(Li)* Li₇₀ZnS₂₄N₈ 0.908 1339.69 1.78 F_(S)* Li₇₁S₂₃N₈F 0.974 1330.59 1.70 Mg_(Li)* Li₇₀MgS₂₄N₈ 0.985 1343.53 1.72 Br_(N)** Li₇₀S₂₄BrN₇ 1.188 1372.28 1.73 Cd_(Li)* Li₇₀CdS₂₄N₈ 1.254 1351.83 1.82 Sr_(Li)* Li₇₀SrS₂₄N₈ 1.501 1369.70 1.76 I_(N)** Li₇₀S₂₄IN₇ 1.681 1386.36 1.77 In_(Li)** Li₆₉InS₂₄N₈ 1.848 1347.53 1.82 La_(Li)** Li₆₉LaS₂₄N₈ 1.938 1363.72 1.83 Be_(Li)** Li₇₀BeS₂₄N₈ 2.299 1330.11 1.72 Ba_(Li)* Li₇₀BaS₂₄N₈ 2.363 1382.5 1.81 Y_(Li)** Li₆₉YS₂₄N₈ 2.415 1354.18 1.78 Sc_(Li)** Li₆₉ScS₂₄N₈ 2.668 1343.49 1.74 Ga_(Li)** Li₆₉GaS₂₄N₈ 2.858 1338.81 1.77 Ge_(Li)** Li₆₈GeS₂₄N₈ 3.057 1335.33 1.77 Al_(Li)** Li₆₉AlS₂₄N₈ 3.575 1334.96 1.73

Cl on the S site and Ca on the Li site are associated with the lowest substitution energy shown in Table 1. From first principles ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) calculations, Cl has a relatively modest effect on conductivity, whereas Ca has a relatively large improvement (See Table 2, below). Table 1 further indicates that Ca on Li has a substitution energy of about 0.848 eV/substitution.

TABLE 2 Summary of AIMD results for Ca and Cl substituted LSN. E_(a) (eV) σ₃₀₀ (S cm⁻¹) Li₉S₃N 0.545 2.35 × 10⁻⁶ Li_(9-x)S_(3-x)Cl_(x)N x 0.125 0.530 3.57 × 10⁻⁶ 0.250 0.486 1.18 × 10⁻⁵ 0.625 0.444 5.90 × 10⁻⁵ Li_(9-2y)Ca_(y)S₃N y 0.125 0.409 7.76 × 10⁻⁵ 0.250 0.295 2.27 × 10⁻³ 0.625 0.268 9.64 × 10⁻³

Therefore, the above data indicates that various forms of LSN, e.g., Ca- and Cl-substituted forms of Li₉S₃N can serve as an effective Li-metal barrier coating. The above data also indicates that functional conductivity is achievable. With the addition of substituents, conductivity can be improved. For example, based on (predicted) performance with respect to ease of synthesis, stability, and high conductivity, the following compound may be synthesized: Li_(9-2x-3y-z)A_(x)B_(y)S_(3-z)C_(z)N₃, where 0.2<x<0.75, 0.1<y<0.5, and 0.25<z<1. Thus, various forms of LSN may be may be used as an electrolyte in low voltage all or substantially all solid state batteries.

FIG. 4 shows the crystallographic structure 400 of undoped Li₉S₃N. The crystallographic structure 400 includes a unit cell 402. The unit cell 402 shown in FIG. 4 has a generally cubic lattice, forming anti-fluorite structure with face-centered cubic anion sublattice.

FIG. 5 shows the crystallographic structure 500 of Ca-doped Li₉S₃N. The crystallographic structure 500 includes a unit cell 502. The unit cell 502 shown in FIG. 5 has a a generally cubic lattice structure type. Notably, the unit cell of the structure of FIG. 5 is defined slightly differently from the unit cell of FIG. 5 to account for Ca-doping

FIG. 6 shows the crystallographic structure 600 of Cl-doped Li₉S₃N. The crystallographic structure 600 includes a unit cell 602. The unit cell 602 shown in FIG. 6 has a cubic lattice structure type. The unit cell of the structure of FIG. 6 is defined in substantially the same manner as the unit cell of FIG. 5 to account for the fat that Cl-doping may achieve a somewhat similar result as for Ca-doping from a crystallographic standpoint.

As shown, both Ca and Cl doping produce a lithium vacancy which resides close to the dopant. Presence of lithium vacancies in the doped Li₉S₃N structures increases the ionic conductivity of such structures relative to that of the undoped structure.

Lattice parameter and crystallographic information for undoped Li₉S₃N can be calculated from the diffraction peaks shown in FIG. 2.

FIG. 7 schematically depicts an exemplary electrochemical cell 700, in accordance with an embodiment. The electrochemical cell 700 includes an anode layer 710 containing an anode material, a cathode layer 730 containing a cathode material, and an electrolyte layer 720 between the anode and cathode layers. A first barrier layer 715 may be provided between the anode layer 710 and the electrolyte layer 720. The first barrier layer 715 can serve to ensure that the anode layer 710 and the electrolyte layer 720 do not react in an undesirable chemical manner. Similarly, a second barrier layer 725 may be provided between the cathode layer 730 and the electrolyte layer 720. The second barrier layer 725 can serve to avoid corrosion occurring between the cathode layer 730 and the electrolyte layer 720. It will be appreciated that one or more components of the cell 700 can be omitted in alternative embodiments. For example, the first and second barrier layers 715, 725 can be omitted.

When the anode layer 710 is metallic lithium, a solid-state Li-conductive material, for example, as described above, may be present in the cathode layer 730, the electrolyte layer 720, and/or one or more barrier layers 715, 725. The solid-state Li-conductive material may be present within the anode layer 710 if the anode layer 710 is formed from a lithium insertion material, e.g., LiC₆.

In some embodiments, the cell 700 may, for example, be a rechargeable solid-state cell. One or more cells may be included in the form of a primary or secondary battery, i.e., a single use or rechargeable battery. The battery may take any of a number of shapes, e.g., a coin shape, a laminate shape, a cylindrical shape and a rectangular shape, etc. The cell may also include an anode current collector electrically coupled with the anode layer and a cathode current collector electrically coupled with the cathode layer.

In an example embodiment, the electrolyte layer 720 contains the solid-state, Li-conductive material. The electrolyte layer 720 typically includes at least 10% to 100% by volume of the Li-conductive material. The electrolyte layer 720 may have a thickness of about 0.1 μm to 1000 μm. Optimally, the electrolyte layer thickness 720 may range from about 0.1 μm to 300 μm. The electrolyte layer 720 may be less than about 0.1 μm if a means for preventing shorting between the anode and cathode layers 710, 730 were provided. Such means may involve processing techniques associated with the electrolyte layer 720 or with the cell 700 as a whole to prevent dendritic growth of an electroactive metal like lithium.

The cathode layer 730 may include a cathode material, the solid electrolyte material, an electrically conductive material and a binder. Cathode active materials suitable for a solid-state lithium battery are typically highly Li-conductive and exhibit a relative high voltage against metallic lithium. In contrast, cathode materials may be ionically nonconductive but electronically conductive.

Microstructurally similar materials used in Li-ion electrochemical cells may be used in an embodiment. For example, FeS₂, MnO₂, spinel LiMn₂O₄, LiCoO₂, LiNiO₂ may serve as electroactive cathode materials. Examples of electrically conductive materials for use in the cathode include acetylene black and graphitic materials. The cathode active material layer may also contain a binder. Exemplary binders include fluorine-containing polymers such as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) and polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF). Examples of current collector materials for the cathode layer include aluminum, nickel, iron, titanium and carbon.

The anode layer 710 includes an anode material and optionally includes the solid electrolyte material, an electrically conductive material, and a binder material. Examples of the anode material include but are not limited to metallic lithium, a metal active material, and a carbon active material. Examples of the metal active material include In, Al, Si, and Sn. Examples of the carbon active material include mesocarbon microbeads (MCMB), high orientation property graphite (HOPG), hard carbon and soft carbon. The electrically conductive material and a binder used for the anode active material layer may be the same as or similar to those contained in the cathode layer. Exemplary anode current collector materials include copper, nickel and carbon.

It is to be understood that, the foregoing description merely illustrates and does not limit the scope of the embodiments described. Numerous alternatives and equivalents exist. For example, there are many different ways to synthesize embodiments of the Li-conductive materials. Alternatives to ball milling such as spray dispersion and other known techniques for mixing starting materials are possible as well. Other aspects, advantages, and modifications will be apparent to those skilled in the art to which the embodiments pertain. 

We claim:
 1. A battery comprising: a sulfide compound of a composition that does not deviate substantially from a formula of Li₉S₃N; and an anode material electrically coupled to the sulfide compound.
 2. The battery of claim 1, wherein the sulfide compound has a conductivity greater than about 5×10⁻⁷ S/cm at about 25° C.
 3. The battery of claim 2, wherein the conductivity of the sulfide compound is greater than about 1×10⁻⁶ S/cm.
 4. The battery of claim 1, wherein the sulfide compound is in contact with metallic lithium at a temperature lower than a melting temperature for metallic lithium.
 5. The battery of claim 1, wherein the sulfide compound is in contact with a lithiated material having a voltage within about 400 mV from metallic lithium's voltage.
 6. The battery of claim 1, wherein the sulfide compound is present in an anode barrier coating.
 7. The battery of claim 1, wherein the sulfide compound is present in an electrolyte.
 8. The battery of claim 1, wherein the sulfide compound has a conductivity of at least 1.0×10⁻⁴ S/cm at a temperature of about 300K.
 9. The battery of claim 1, wherein the sulfide compound has a formula of Li_(9-2x-3y-z)A_(x)B_(y)S_(3-z)C_(z)N₃, where 0≦x<4.5, 0≦y<3, and 0≦z<3.
 10. The battery of claim 9, wherein the formula is Li_(9-2x-3y-z)A_(x)B_(y)S_(3-z)C_(z)N₃, where 0.2≦x <0.75, 0.1≦y<0.5, and 0.25≦z<1.
 11. The battery of claim 9, wherein A is selected from Ca, Zn, Mg, Cd, Sr, Ba and Be; B is selected from F, Cl, Br, and I, and C is selected from In, La, Be, Y, Sc, Ga and Al.
 12. The battery of claim 1, the sulfide compound having an activation energy no greater than about 1 eV at about 25° C.
 13. The battery of claim 12, the sulfide compound having an activation energy no greater than about 0.6 eV at about 25° C.
 14. An electrochemical cell comprising: an anode layer containing an anode material; a cathode layer containing a cathode material; and an electrolyte layer between the anode and cathode layers, wherein a solid-state, alkali-ion conductive material is present in the cathode layer, the electrolyte layer, or both, the material comprising a sulfide compound of a composition that does not deviate substantially from a formula of Li₉S₃N, having a conductivity greater than about 1×10⁻⁷ S/cm at about 25° C.
 15. The electrochemical cell of claim 14, wherein the cell is a solid-state cell.
 16. A lithium-conductive solid-state material comprising a sulfide compound of a formula Li_(a)S_(b)N_(c), having a conductivity greater than about 1×10⁻⁷ S/cm and an activation energy no greater than about 0.52 eV at about 25° C.
 17. The material of claim 16, wherein 8≦a≦15, 2≦b≦4, 0.5≦c≦3.
 18. The material of claim 16, wherein the activation energy is no greater than about 0.5 eV at about 25° C.
 19. The material of claim 18, wherein the activation energy is no greater than about 0.4 eV at about 25° C.
 20. The material of claim 19, wherein the activation energy is no greater than about 0.29 eV at about 25° C. 